Best Toaster in 2026 — Cuisinart, Breville & More Tested
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, we earn from qualifying purchases. How we test →
Last updated: May 19, 2026 • 20+ toasters tested
- Cuisinart CPT-160 — Best overall (4.8/5)
- Breville BTA820XL Bit More — Best upgrade (4.6/5)
- Smeg TSF01 — Best design premium (4.3/5)
Browning consistency is what separates a good toaster from a frustrating one — cheap models heat unevenly, burning the bottom while leaving the top pale. Unfortunately most toasters don't last long regardless of price, which is why the 3-year warranty on our top pick matters as much as its performance. These five deliver the best results across price points.
Quick Overview
| Toaster | Best for | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart CPT-160 | Best overall Best Pick | ★★★★☆ 4.8 |
| Breville BTA820XL Bit More | Best upgrade Runner-up | ★★★★½ 4.6 |
| Smeg TSF01 | Best design premium | ★★★★½ 4.3 |
| BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice | Best budget 2-slice | ★★★★½ 4.4 |
| Cuisinart CPT-142 | Best 4-slice Best Budget | ★★★★½ 4.5 |
1. Cuisinart CPT-160 2-Slice — Best Overall
The Cuisinart CPT-160 browned bread more evenly than almost any other toaster tested across two years of testing — an unassuming ~$37 plastic toaster that consistently outperforms models costing three to four times as much. The 3-year warranty is the longest in the category at this price, which matters because toasters don't last like they used to regardless of brand. Six browning settings, wide slots, and a bagel function round out a machine that does one thing exceptionally well.
- Browned most evenly of all models tested across multiple test rounds
- 3-year warranty — longest at this price point
- ~$37 — exceptional value for proven performance
- Wide slots accommodate thick slices and bagels
- Plain plastic design — no aesthetic statement
- Can be difficult to find in stock at the lowest prices
2. Breville BTA820XL Bit More — Best Upgrade
The Breville BTA820XL's standout feature is the "A Bit More" button — it adds extra toasting time without resetting the browning dial, solving the common frustration of slightly underdone toast with a single press. Die-cast metal construction, a high-lift lever for small bread products, and a self-adjusting slot width that accommodates everything from thin sliced bread to thick artisan loaves. The upgrade pick for households that toast daily and want a more considered design.
- "A Bit More" button — adds time without resetting dial
- Self-adjusting slot width handles any bread thickness
- High-lift lever for small bread and crumpets
- Die-cast metal — more durable than plastic body alternatives
- More expensive than Cuisinart CPT-122 for similar browning performance
- Breville less widely available outside US/UK
3. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Toaster — Best Budget
The BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice delivers reliable everyday toasting at a price that makes it easy to recommend without hesitation. Extra-wide slots handle thick artisan bread, bagels, and English muffins. Six browning settings, bagel mode, defrost, and cancel functions cover all standard use cases. It won't win any design awards, but for households that just need consistent toast without spending much, it's the straightforward choice.
- Extra-wide slots — handles thick bread, bagels, and muffins
- 6 browning settings with defrost and bagel functions
- Compact footprint for small kitchens
- Reliable everyday performance at a very accessible price
- Browning consistency below Cuisinart CPT-160 in testing
- Plain plastic design — purely functional
4. Smeg TSF01 — Best Premium European Design
The Smeg TSF01 is Italian retro design at its most refined — available in 10+ colours including cream, red, black, and pastels, it's the most visually cohesive toaster available and pairs with the Smeg kettle and other small appliances. 6 browning levels, bagel and defrost functions, and a cool-touch exterior. At ~€120 it's bought as much for what it looks like as what it does, but the performance is solid for daily use.
- Italian retro design — available in 10+ colours
- Coordinates with Smeg kettle and appliance range
- 6 browning levels, cool-touch exterior
- ~€120 — significant design premium over performance-equivalent alternatives
- Browning consistency below Cuisinart at double the price
5. Cuisinart CPT-142 4-Slice — Best 4-Slot
The Cuisinart CPT-142 is the 4-slot version of our best overall pick — the same even-browning performance in a 4-slice format. Two independent pairs of slots allow you to toast two or four slices simultaneously, each with independent browning settings. At a similar accessible price point to its 2-slice sibling, it's the straightforward choice for households that need more capacity without paying a significant premium.
- 4 slots with two independent browning controls
- Same even-browning performance as CPT-122
- Compact footprint for a 4-slot toaster
- 3-year warranty — same as the 2-slice model
- Plain plastic design — purely functional
- Takes up more counter space than 2-slot alternatives
What to Look for in a Toaster
Browning consistency
The most important factor. Good toasters brown evenly from top to bottom and edge to edge. Cheap toasters heat unevenly, burning the bottom while leaving the top pale. Testing consistently shows this is not correlated with price — the Cuisinart CPT-160 at $37 out-browns toasters costing $150+.
Slot width
Standard slots (19–24mm) handle standard sliced bread. Wide slots (28–35mm) handle artisan bread, sourdough, bagels, and crumpets. All five picks above have wide enough slots for most bread types.
Warranty
Toasters fail faster than they used to — even premium models. The Cuisinart CPT-122's 3-year warranty is the longest at its price tier and significantly reduces the risk of the most frustrating outcome: an expensive toaster that dies after 18 months.
The "A Bit More" problem
One of the most common toaster frustrations is toast that's slightly underdone but restarting the cycle over-browns it. The Breville BTA720XL solves this with a dedicated button that adds just a bit more time without resetting the dial.
Our Verdict
The Cuisinart CPT-160 is the best toaster for most households — it browns more evenly than almost any competitor tested, at $37 with a 3-year warranty. For the upgrade experience, the Breville BTA820XL's "A Bit More" button solves a real daily frustration. For European design-first kitchens, the Smeg TSF01 is unmatched on counter presence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Pop-up toaster or toaster oven — which should I buy?
Pop-up toaster (Cuisinart CPT-160, Breville BTA820XL): faster, simpler, better for daily toast/bagels. Toaster oven: more versatile (broils, reheats, bakes), takes more counter space, slower. For breakfast-focused households: pop-up. For households wanting one appliance to replace toaster + small oven: toaster oven. They serve different purposes; many households have both.
Two-slice or four-slice toaster?
Two-slice (1-2 person households): adequate, less counter space. Four-slice (3+ person households): saves time when feeding multiple people, allows toasting different breads at different settings simultaneously. The Breville Bit More 2-Slice is excellent for couples. Most four-slice toasters have separate side controls — useful when one person wants light toast and another wants dark.
How do I get evenly browned toast?
Match bread to toaster: even-sliced bread (Hovis, Warburtons) browns more evenly than artisan sourdough with irregular thickness. Higher-quality toasters (Breville) have dual heating elements that brown both sides equally. The auto-shutoff timer adjusts for ambient kitchen temperature on premium models. For uneven browning, flip slices halfway through cycle.
Are bagel-specific toaster settings useful?
Yes if you eat bagels regularly. Bagel mode toasts the inside (cut side) more aggressively while keeping the crust softer. Without this mode, bagels burn on the outside before the inside heats. The Cuisinart CPT-160 and Breville BTA820XL both have dedicated bagel settings. For bread-only households, the feature is irrelevant.